The Bagel Shop of Tenafly

They served me old deli meat?? There were suspicious brown deli meats in my italian sandwich so I ended up eating only the bread, which was rough and dry... Also there was not enough lettuce.. We had also ordered the John Wayne sandwich which didn't come with lettuce tomato onion so I guess you need to specifically ask for that..... Can't speak for the bagels but the sandwiches are terrible so will not come here again...

Yeah I don’t think I will be back. 13.00 for a chicken salad bagel where the chicken salad tastes expired is definitely not good for your business. Just threw money out the door and have to go get something else.

As soon as you walk in all you see is cross contamination and the one man show of a “chef” cooks with his me glove and you guessed it, the hand without a glove was prepping the bagel. Their prices are higher than most places in town. There is a reason this place is always empty the guy is rude and will not take constructive criticism. He told me if I was not happy I could go elsewhere.

Their prices have become absolutely outrageous in the last year. 3 stars bc food is good but their prices are crazy and not worth it! I can sit down in a restaurant and order a full meal for the same price they charge for a deli or breakfast sandwich!

Beware! Most expensive in area. Overpriced, coffee weak, bagel hard as rock. Stinks.