That Guy's Pizza

In town for spring training and staying nearby. It was getting late when we got into town so That Guys was one of few nearby choices. I was a little concerned when we rolled in and no one else was inside, but ordered a supreme pie and standard salad to go. Staff were attentive and completed the order quickly. Salad was as expected but the pizza was unexpectedly good: solid crust, decent sauce and toppings were on point. Will eat here again next time I'm out. Thank you

Just want to start with my appreciation of this gem, thank you! It’s rare to find a pizza where the crust truly complements the toppings. This pizza boasts that perfect ‘leopard-spotting’ on the bottom! It’s crispy enough to hold its own but with a pillowy, airy chew. The sauce isn’t just an afterthought; it’s bright, slightly sweet, and clearly fresh. If you’re a fan of a well-balanced pie that doesn’t rely on grease to provide flavor, this is your new benchmark. My go-to is THAT GUY!

After reopening under new management, the pizza is fantastic and the ranch is amazing. We’ve ordered twice since it reopened and both times were so delicious and the owners were so nice when we picked up. Any old reviews prior to reopening should be taken lightly as the quality is far superior now, especially the crust. I’d even go as far as saying that we prefer That Guys over Streets of New York.

What a great place! The owners are so nice and always have a smile on their face. The pizza is excellent; we like a pepperoni, sausage, and black olive pie. Wings are tasty and crispy and love their antipasti salad. Highly recommend this place. We have not eaten at the restaurant but it reminds me of my childhood pizza joint in NY. Nothing fancy but great food, staff and clean.

My wife and I ordered a large Supreme Pizza along with a salad. The pizza was cooked perfectly. The crust was excellent. The salad was made with all fresh ingredients and a fantastic tasting Caesar dressing. Looking forward to eating the leftovers. ;) The owners were sweet and aimed to please in all aspect of the experience. Highly recommend and would go back in a heartbeat if we lived in the area.