Tallarico's Pizzeria

Best pizza place around hands down! Been coming here since I was a teenager and still doesn't disappoint. Prices are great and makes it even better it's all family owned and runned. They always make sure your food is perfect and consistent unlike many other places in the area. Keep up the great work and thanks for the amazing food!

Its been a while since I have had Tallarico's pizza and I ordered delivery today. How did I ever let them slip my mind?? Probably because I don't order out much. Nonetheless, this pizza is still as amazing as I remember. The crust cooked to perfection. Light and crisp with cornmeal on the bottom. That in itself is a BONUS!! Just the right amount of sauce (not dripping out) and toppings. Years ago their Old Fashioned was my go to when I would take my horse to friends in Gasport for trail riding. Everyone would be looking for the pizza the minute I pulled up. LOL Tallarico's would have this ready for me before they opened. I called a day ahead. So accommodating. I will not overlook this gem of a pizzeria again!

Had lunch there today. It was so good. We love place, best around. Thank you for great comfort food on cold winters day.

Got a cheese and pep...could use a Lil more pepperoni but still was very enjoyable chatted with whom I think might be the owner which was a good convo very clean and well looking establishment

We’re from out of town and were driving by and decided to stop and get a bite to eat. The pizza was made fresh and was so tasty! The owners were really kind and hospitable. If we ever come back this way, we’ll definitely be back!