Sweet Mary's

Adorable shop!! Very nice staff. Cupcakes were amazing!! We got a strawberry cheesecake and a black pink. It was Not overly sweet and the cupcake was moist and fresh. Loved it!

I had a “lunchbox” cupcake - yellow cake & chocolate icing, I think buttercream. I usually find that cupcakes are too dry. This was moist but not mushy and absolutely delicious! I would have been perfectly happy with the cupcake even if it wasn’t iced.

This was my second visit to this bakery. I first tried it about three years ago when I lived across the street. Back then, it was just okay, but I decided to give it another shot based on some recent positive reviews. Unfortunately, this visit was underwhelming. The cupcakes I received were cold, almost frozen, which really affected the texture and flavor. They were just average, not bad, but nothing memorable. At $5 per cupcake (plus tax and a suggested tip), I ended up spending $17 for three. For that price, I expected a fresher, more enjoyable cupcake There are definitely more affordable and better-quality options in the area. That said, the store itself is adorable. The aesthetic and decor are charming and inviting. I just wish the product matched the vibe.

Pretty little bakery shop tucked away in downtown New Haven. There’s lots of gorgeous cookware items to feast your eyes on, in addition to the wonderful desserts. The owner was very kind. I had the salted caramel and cannoli cupcakes - pillowy perfection! I loved how soft and not overwhelming the icings and flavors were. Would definitely stop in again!

Lovely 10/10. The lady working was very sweet and knowledgeable. The cupcakes were AMAZING and SO fresh. Would go back every day if I could. Love it!