Super Secret Ice Cream

This place is pure happiness in ice cream form! The person helping us was so nice and told us we could sample as many flavors as we wanted, total dream come true. I got the Earl Grey Tea ice cream and OMG it was unreal. I honestly thought Toscanini Ice Cream in Cambridge, MA had the best Earl Grey Tea ice cream, but this place totally wins. My husband got the Honeycomb in a waffle cone and was obsessed with both the cone and the ice cream. Their logos give total designer vibes and are just too cute. The sweatshirts are adorable and there were so many souvenir options I wanted to take one of everything. We also got a pup cup for our dog and he finished it in one second. Can’t wait to come back for round two! 🍦🐶✨

Wow. This might be the best ice cream I’ve had so far in the U.S. At first, I thought the high ratings were just people riding a post-hike sugar high (and honestly, that might still be partly true). But most of the flavors I tried were genuinely fantastic. The ice cream flight came out to almost two pints, and even in shorts on a 50°F evening, we wiped it clean in under five minutes. The flavors weren’t wild or experimental. Everything’s made in small batches, so the lineup seemed to change often. I didn’t see many of the flavors mentioned in older reviews, but 5/6 were hits. The sugar level was relatively restrained (by U.S. standards), so no sticky, sugary aftertaste. Also liked how they made the berry ice cream with yogurt. Ranking the lineup: Cantaloupe (my Melona bias) > Honey Comb

Had the wonderful privilege of stopping at Super Secret twice in two days on a recent trip! Both times the service and quality was just beyond compare. The staff is kind, knowledgeable, and accommodating. The ice cream is always amazing and features expertly executed twists on common and uncommon flavors. The Blueberry Basil with a hint of cinnamon and the Slopeside Mint Chip were the standouts for our group. Can’t wait to go back!

Delicious ice cream. Small menu of local flavors with local ingredients and artisan prices ($5 for one small scoop.) In addition to unique flavors, they also had chocolate, strawberry and an awesome vanilla. I recommend a flight for economy and taste: they don’t have these flavors anywhere else. Try them here!

Amazing ice cream and waffle cones. We did not get any food just ice cream. Only coffee and chocolate are recognizable. All the others are unique flavors and very yummy. They will let you taste any or all of them. The waffle cones are delicious. Highly recommended. Great service. Best ice cream around. Today’s flavors in picture below.