Sunset Club Plum Island

The staff and atmosphere are one of a kind. Nothing beats sitting outside on a warm summer day. They also had a fire pit with Adirondack chairs, which we would have loved to enjoy if the weather had been a bit cooler. The drink and food menu are about the same size. While we weren't huge fans of the food, they knocked it out of the park with their cocktail menu. The Two Point Cake was light and refreshing - I highly recommend it. Our party split the pulled pork tacos, which were the highlight of the food we tasted. Overall, we had a great time!

I always try to visit every time I'm in the area. Staff are always welcoming and the food and cocktails are always excellent. The burger I ordered was extra juicy this time around and the herbed potatoes with shaved parmesan was an excellent combination. Order the Bait and Tackle if you like a spicy cocktail!

The atmosphere is fantastic—great vibes, stylish decor, and an unbeatable view, especially at sunset. It’s a perfect spot to unwind with friends or enjoy a laid-back evening. The food was decent, not exceptional, but enjoyable. That said, prices felt a bit steep for what you get. You’re mostly paying for the location and ambiance—but that part truly delivers.

Location is great, service was friendly but food and drinks were bleh. We ordered the poke bowl, wings, and spicy margarita. The poke bowl was so so, fish was fresh but rice was way overcooked. The wings were blueberry gojuchang with lemon buttermilk ranch which was just a really weird and not good flavor combo. The spicy margarita was so sweet I couldn’t drink it and ended up sending it back. Would consider going back but prob would stick to beer or wine and maybe skip food.

Great place for drinks & sunset. Food is not great, we tried the fish tacos and cocktail shrimp. Will keep it simple and get a burger next time! Friendly service, lively bar, fire pit, plenty of tables and parking, overall good spot.