Sugarplum Cake Shoppe

We had an incredible experience with Sugarplum Cake Shoppe for our wedding! They created a fall in the mountains themed cutting cake that was so delicious! We selected a dessert bar for our guests which was very popular! We had a great experience with Amanda for our tasting and were able to get to go boxes of the desserts so we could try everything we were interested in! We can’t recommend them highly enough!! :)

We had our wedding cake tasting here and couldn’t have asked for a better experience. From start to finish, it felt relaxed, fun, and completely focused on what we wanted for our wedding day. There was zero pressure, just thoughtful guidance, great conversation, and plenty of transparency around pricing, packages, and what options might affect our budget. It made the whole process feel exciting instead of overwhelming. We left feeling confident, heard, and genuinely excited to see how our wedding cake turns out later this year. Highly recommend to any couples looking for a stress-free and enjoyable cake tasting experience

Our wedding cake from SugarPlum was absolutely amazing! It was not only gorgeous to look at but also so delicious, we received so many compliments from our guests. The team at was wonderful and so easy to work with, which made the whole process stress-free. We couldn’t have asked for a better cake for our special day!

Expectation vs Reality lol. In all seriousness, the cake was good and this review is admittedly very late as I got married a few years ago (but I was asked by a friend about this bakery recently and it jogged my memory). So, the cake didn't really turn out visually how I expected. I didn't love that you could clearly see the cardboard bases between the layers and the flowers were positioned a bit haphazardly. They also told me I would receive a 1 yr anniversary mini cake as part of my wedding package--which I never received. Overall not a bad cake experience but I also don't know that I'd honestly sing their praises.

We had out wedding cake and desserts here the cookies were fabulous. However the cake was not what we had pictured yes it still looked nice but it wasn't what we envisioned we wanted rose gold flakes which we were quoted and was attached to the cake bill. the cakes flavor was good but not much in the way of the filling. Inspo pic attached as well for reference. (yes inspo is 3 layers we only wanted 2)