Sugar Bowl Millersville

I’ve been here a few times, during the most busy and during the not at all. I don’t follow the logic that how long it takes them to prepare the food is always the same amount of time, but their cheeseburgers are the best. I’ve gotten pizza and it was mediocre but still better than some name brands. Would definitely recommend just keep in mind it’s a little pricey.

Really is an amazing place will delicious, real, and fresh food. Greatly priced too! I come here very often and highly recommend.

I'm from Lancaster and live in NYC and you can't even get a stromboli in NYC at all (only calzone, yuck). I've only previously ever had them in Philly. Meanwhile I come back to Lancaster for the weekend and find one of the best strombolis I've ever had here in Millersville. Was not expecting that! Keep it up folks.

I've been hearing about the Sugar Bowl for decades via my husband's family and finally had the opportunity to try it. The cheesesteak and cold cut subs were quite large and tasty. Will be my go to place going forward.

It is definitely a cool college hangout being right next to the stadium. The staff was friendly and place was clean. The food was so so. Not sure I'd go there again. There was a lot to pick from though.