Stellina Ristorante

Plan for a special evening in this amazing restaurant. The service is attentive and helpful, from explaining the menu and anticipating your needs. The regional food was unusual and full of surprises. We tried fennel salad with oranges and pork belly porchetta. It was so good I forgot to take a picture until I ate one of the pieces.

Stellina Ristorante is honestly one of the best places to go. The vibe inside is so warm and comfortable and the staff is so amazing. Everyone is so kind, attentive, and just makes you feel at home the second you come in. The food is always incredible. I loveee their pizza, it’s always the perfect mix of crispy and flavorful. And the calamari? Easily some of the best. I’m obsessed. Great people, great food, great atmosphere. Couldn’t recommend Stellina more!

The food would have tasted better with a little more salt and maybe a kick from red pepper flakes. Every dish tasted a little bland. But it was still overall good food and ambiance. I felt sorry for the staff. It was only 3 people taking care of several tables. The hostess in the front was running around and taking orders, packing food, and bringing food back and bringing the drinks to the table and seating customers and answering the phone. And there was 1 bartender who was also running to tables to take orders in between making drinks. And there was a young boy who was also running to each table to serve food and pack food. I asked my husband if they were short-staffed or is it always like this? The service was slower because of this so I am hoping they were just short-staffed and that

This restaurant is extremely small and intimate. The food is simply beyond words for me, they present such a wild array of different flavors for each dish. Everything that touched our table was a treat. I cannot recommend this place enough. If I did have any complaints, they usher you out of there immediately, upon bill payment. Given it's size, I guess that is to be expected.

A little gem with amazing Italian authentic food. Sometimes you randomly find these little spots that turn out to be a treasure. The ambiance is immaculate, it feels cozy and warm. We tried different plates and everything was tasty, a piece of Italy right here in Oyster Bay. We tried bucatini ala amatriciana, agnolotti with tartufo, meatball, octopus, pizza, the bone-in ribeye, fritto misto, etc. The service was great, the chief greeted us and explained a few of the dishes. I’d recommend Stellina and we’ll definitely come back again.