Stefano's Pizzeria

We accidentally found this restaurant while stopping for gas. I was so excited when I saw how cute it was from the outside and nothing disappointed. We brought home three cannolis to share and although I have not tried one yet, I am certain they are going to be excellent! The pizza crust was perfect!

Absolutely amazing experience! The service was friendly and attentive from the moment we walked in. The food was delicious — you can really taste the quality and care in every dish. We finished our meal with their homemade gelato and cannoli, and both were out of this world! Easily one of the best Italian spots.

We had a party catered by Stephano’s in Pompton Plains, and it was amazing. Everything was excellent—the delivery was right on time, delivery guy so nice. The owners are wonderful, and the food was outstanding. We even had guests from out of town, and everyone loved it. We had 6 foot sub, meatballs, pasta, chicken parm, and sausage and peppers—everything was delicious. It truly made the party. The owners are so nice, and you wouldn’t be disappointed. Definitely give them a try!”

Wonderful restaurant. And a must for the variety of desserts... Highly recommended.

Had a great experience at this pizzeria! The food was super tasty, fresh, and full of flavor. The staff was really friendly and made sure everything was perfect. It’s the kind of place where you feel welcome as soon as you walk in. Definitely coming back!