Stachey's Pizza

The pizza was good but needed to be reheated upon arrival. No problem, easy fix. I also ordered the fried pickles.. This is where my problem lies. The restaurant is less than a mile away from my Airbnb. At worst, I expected them to lose crunch in transport but what I received is much worse. All batter(to their credit, very crunchy) and slivers of what seem to be re-fried, very thinly cut pickles… I feel like for $10.50 they dropped them in the fryer, pulled them out, let them sit too long and had to drop them in the fryer again. The fact that someone actually looked at these pickles and decided this product met service standard is wild. The fried pickles should be removed from the menu.

I was visiting a customer in the area and was starving... went in to Stachey's Pizza for a small turkey sub to go. I could not believe the size of the sub! It was twice as big as any small sub I've ever ordered and it may have been a mistake... but it was a delicious mistake. Great quality bread, meat, cheese, veggies and the right amount of mayo. Very impressed.

Clean establishment. Friendly service. Delicious pizza. New York style. Sauce has a hint of sweetness but not overwhelmingly so. Can't wait to try a sub next time!

Ordered large mushroom and pepper pizza. Pictures speak for themselves. Pizza was raw and when I called they tried to replace it with another for which the second one was raw as well. Both were thrown out. We have tried to give this place several opportunities and always issues with the quality of the food. Lost two customers. Amore is ten times better and owners are fantastic people and no attitude.

Generous salad portions with excellent grilled and/or teriyaki chicken. Salads come with a complimentary homemade warm pita and you can’t beat their prices and friendliness. Pizzas are also outstanding.