South Island Pizza

⭐ Best Pizza in Islamorada 11-Star Experience! ⭐ South Island Pizza delivered one of the best meals we’ve had in the Keys. Amanda and her family run this place with unbeatable kindness, speed, and true pride in their food. The slices are huge, the crust is perfect, the garlic knots are addictive, and even the burgers are next-level good. The service is lightning fast, the dining room is spotless, and you feel like family the moment you sit down. If you’re anywhere near Islamorada, stop what you’re doing and try this place you’ll be glad you did. Highly recommended!

South Island Pizza is awesome! I go here all the time and love that it’s a truly local spot — owned and operated by people who actually care about their customers. The staff is super friendly and you really get to know them. The sauce is amazing — tons of flavor and no heartburn (huge win!). Everything tastes fresh, and I literally saw the cook walk out to pick fresh basil for my pizza. How cool is that?! They’re always running great specials, and you have to try the Chicken Parm Pizza — absolutely superb. Easily my favorite pizza place around! 🍕🙌

If you’re in Islamorada and craving amazing pizza, you need to check out South Island Pizza! 🍕 The locals who opened this spot truly know what they’re doing — the pizza is absolutely delicious, loaded with flavor, and cooked to perfection. Every bite has that perfect balance of crispy crust, gooey cheese, and generous toppings. On top of the food, the service is outstanding. The owners are so welcoming, and you can really feel the pride they put into every pizza that comes out of the oven. 👉 Whether you’re a local or just visiting, do yourself a favor: come out, taste the amazing pizza, and meet the incredible people behind it. You won’t regret it!

Very clean, welcoming place with attentive and friendly staff. Our pizza was ready in about ten minutes, which was a nice surprise. We got a 16" Margherita pizza. The crust is PERFECT. Crunchy and chewy... yum. The ingredients were fresh and delicious. We'll be back soon! Thank you!

Such a wonderful, family-owned and operated pizzeria! You can really taste the love and care that goes into every bite. The ingredients are always fresh, the crust is perfect, and the flavors are amazing. The staff makes you feel like part of the family, and the atmosphere is welcoming. This is the kind of local spot that keeps you coming back again and again. 🍕❤️