Smitty's Homemade Ice Cream

Just don’t. Don’t. Wow. This place changed management and it’s really bad. I asked for a hot fudge sundae. I asked if it was hot fudge or chocolate sauce. I was told hot fudge. It was not. It was some kind of rubbery, cold and dark substance with cardboard flavored whipped cream. I had to return it. The sundae was NOT worth $9. The atmosphere is depressing and crowded with boxes. They removed the tables and trash can from outside. You will have a MUCH better time and product at Whitts. Finally, I do not blame the teenager that waited on us.

Over $10 for a brownie sundae. It barely had any ice cream in it. The brownie was definitely not homemade & not warm. It had a crunchy exterior & not in a good way. Whipped cream had an oily under taste to it. Cherries were nasty & tasted like they were going bad.

Me, my dad and another guy that works with us while in the work truck to hopefully use the bathroom and get some ice cream. We couldn’t use the restroom because it was blocked off so we just went on and ordered anyway. My dad got a vanilla milkshake that was almost pure milk and not good at all. Not to mention a 16oz shake was $8. I ordered a hot fudge sundae and the so called hot fudge was literally chewy 🤨 he said did I want whipped cream and I said yes so he pulled out a bowl that had liquid something and scooped on it with a spoon 🤦‍♀️ and charged me $8.49 for that and 2 scoops of vanilla ice cream. I had to literally throw out all the “fudge” it was so gross but tried to eat the ice cream at least and peanuts so I didn’t waste all my money. Needless to say I will not be going back the

Cute little place. Homemade ice-cream was very special. The mango was very rich, and the pink lemonade sorbet was fantastic. Waffle bowl was fresh. My wife commented the cotton candy was great without tasting like pure sugar. Also Jim was very kind, friendly and helpful. Would recommend. Also the prices were very fair.

Very cluttered inside, do not recommend mint ice-cream. It's like eating frozen toothpaste. My spouse had the waffle bowl with butter pecan and that was really good. The cashier was very polite.