Shugah Hill Bakery

Stopped in to visit the pottery place next door and saw this adorable bakery. I saw a sign fresh bagels and decided to pop in for some. In the display case, they had a Key Lime Pie ($35), may be pricey... but it was made from scratch and authentic to the local flavor (being originally from the Florida Keys). 4.5 out of 5 stars. They offered Tuna & Chicken salad sandwiches and that intrigued me... for next time!! Highly recommend stopping in and supporting this local small business.

Heard some good things about Shugah Hill Bakery and thought we would try it. Stopped into the store and right away there was a not so pleasant odor instead the store rather than the usual expected freshly baked goods smell. The store is nicely decorated. Not many selections to choose from on display. Chose a blueberry cake, a mini chocolate Bundt cake, oatmeal cookie and almond biscotti. The oatmeal cookie was a bit mushy and fell apart as I picked it up and the flavor was a bit too sweet for my taste. The rest of the pastries were either tasteless or not enough of something. The texture of the Bundt cake was like a flourless cake, dry, dense and stale. The blueberry cake was also dry and stale. Will not be going back again.

I recently stopped into Sugah hill to grab a birthday cake for my husband, we weren’t picky about what we wanted so I figured I would just grab anything from th case along with some other cookies etc. There was a great selection of cakes as well as cookies muffins and bars. The staff were honestly some of the most genuinely friendly and happy people I have come across in a store. I chose a chocolate cake from the case it was decorated in a modern and delightful way. It was OUTSTANDING. This cake was so fudgy but not dense somehow. And the chocolate flavor was very deep and multifaceted. Not flat. I also bought myself a vanilla cupcake to eat I am obsessed with vanilla and the cake and frosting were luscious. The texture was beyond moist and tasted of butter and vanilla I was in heaven. I b

Sugah Hill Bakery continues to set the bar for what a local bakery should be. Beyond their exceptional everyday pastries, this is a place that truly shines when it comes to beautiful custom-order cakes and outstanding pies. Their custom cakes are not only visually stunning—clearly made with precision and pride—but they also deliver where it matters most: flavor, texture, and balance. These are celebration-worthy cakes that look as good as they taste. The pies deserve special mention as well. Perfectly baked crusts, generous fillings, and flavors that feel classic yet elevated. Whether fruit-based or cream, they strike that rare balance between homemade comfort and professional execution. Across the board, everything here reflects care and craftsmanship. Cakes are moist and well-balanced,

Shugah Hill Bakery is a local gem. You can’t go wrong with anything you may purchase there. I have had their pies, sweets, the coffee cake is just like what my Grammy would bring from NY when I was young. And now the bagels and homemade cream cheese are phenomenal! Not to mention their lattes. You don’t need all the sugary syrup. Yum! The owners and staff are friendly and the atmosphere is cozy. You just can’t go wrong!