Sherwood Diner

We had a pretty disappointing visit to Sherwood Diner. The food was mediocre at best, and the service was frustrating. Our server walked away mid-order without saying anything, which was awkward and unprofessional, and it was difficult to get his attention again afterward. The diner wasn’t busy, so the lack of attentiveness stood out even more. To make matters worse, the food was expensive and not worth the value. Our steak and shrimp scampi looked very sad and was far from appetizing, especially for the price. Overall, this experience missed the mark across the board. We won’t be back, I’d honestly rather go to IHOP down the road.

Dined here with a group of 6 after arriving from JFK Airport after a long flight home. Was seated promptly by a cheerful person. Immediately received water and the best part, cole slaw, mac salad, large basket of rolls, crackers, breadsticks and some of the best pickles we ever had. Our order was then taken and served at a nice pace. Menu was huge as were the very generous portions. Everything was outstanding in quality and all 6 of us had doggie bags at the end of the meal. Very nice job Sherwood Diner - plan to visit again when around JFK Airport.

Spacious and welcoming, with a nostalgic old-school vibe. The menu has all the American comfort food favorites, and the portions are generous. Service was friendly and fast. Perfect spot for a casual meal any time of day. Highly recommend!

We passed that place many times and finally gave it a try and went for breakfast. The food turned out to be just ok and underwhelming by diner standards. The staff was not very polite and didn't seem to be caring although our simple order was prepared as we wanted. The owner was friendly and welcoming on the other hand. Not writing this place off however and will give it another try someday.

Was in the neighborhood and decided to try out this diner! To my surprise they were great! Super good food, big portion size and nice/ attentive stand. My roast beef sandwich was so delicious can’t wait to go back!