Sherrill New York Pizzeria

Medium -1/2 cheese, 1/2 pepperoni/banana pepper. Good pricing, right @ $20. Good Customer service. Pizza review: Sauce too sweet, has a flop to it, which, I personally don't prefer. The Crust was absolutely amazing though. Perfectly cooked and tasty, but the sweetness was too much for me personally, so 4 stars. Still recomend if you're in the Sherrill/Verona area to try it out!

This place use to be my favorite pizza in town . The food is good DONT get me wrong but when pull up and the entire staff doesn’t even have a mask on it’s a hard no for me and my kids . Maybe next year will try this place again . Edit : April 30th we have now tried another year and same thing no mask however on the from door it says customers just wear a mask for service . The cheese pizza has more lumps on it smh . I gave it another shot but that was the last time .it was very bland 😖😖

Great tasting sweet sauce. My pizza was grossly undercooked and basically a layer of raw dough.

Super disappointed with how this restaurant has ‘rebranded’. Basically if your beliefs don’t align with theirs, you aren’t welcome there. This is why the political divide continues to grow deeper. You can’t even get a pizza anymore without a far right agenda shoved in your face. As for the pizza, it was incredibly greasy. I thought cheese would be a little less grease but I was mistaken. The wings and salad are great and this place is practically around the corner from us but sadly we won’t be back because it’s clear we aren’t welcome there.

For a long time I have been getting the same things from here, and today i decided to try a Philly Steak sub. No cap the best sub i have ever eaten subway aint got nothing on this.