Sheldons Street Pizza

Its a pick up only, no done in. Friendly staff and delicious pizza. We had a BLT and. Meatlovers. It was my first time having the BLT and it was amazing. Can't wait to try some of their other creations.

My husband and I were in the area for our anniversary and decided to try something new. Found this as a highly rated restaurant online so decided to try it. It FAR exceeded our expectations and the staff was incredible and went above and beyond ehat I have ever seen at a restaurant. I'm assuming I spoke to the owner who was so amazingly kind and the other person working gave amazing suggestions as well. I have never met such incredible people while at a pizza place. They seemed to know everyone that entered by name in my short time waiting. It was so neat to witness that kind of community. Once we got our food I realized the reviews don't even do it justice. We got 2 different types of pizza and some breadsticks and oh my word.... Best pizza we have ever tasted 100%! The crust was absolut

Yummy 😋 Hands down, the dough is fantastic. The cheese and toppings taste fresh and their ratios are spot on. It really felt like it was made with love. New go to 🙌 The owner and two team members working were personable and attentive too, which was really nice because it was my first time visiting. Thank you to the Sheldon team 🙏

Sheldon’s Street Pizza never disappoints. The food is consistently outstanding—fresh, flavorful, and clearly made with care every single time we visit. Beyond the incredible pizza, what truly sets this place apart is the owner. His professionalism, generosity, and character are evident in every interaction. On one occasion, I mistakenly ordered from the wrong location, and instead of turning me away, he graciously reopened his kitchen to make it right. That kind of integrity and hospitality is rare. It’s clear he runs his business with strong values, faith, and a genuine commitment to serving people well. Sheldon’s Street Pizza is more than a great meal—it’s a place run by someone who truly cares.

The best pizza in the Orion area. Sheldon's has been the pizza joint since it was in the Orion Keg and Wine and I'm happy to say they are still as good if not better than ever. The order was ready a few moments faster than even predicted and was piping hot. The service in the store and on the phone was excellent as always. The atmosphere is great, the store is clean, and they are organized. We had a pizza and a Calzone and both were excellent. We will continue to order and recommend Sheldon's to all. Highest recommendation.