Serafina's Pizzeria

Ordered here to try something new. What a pleasant surprise. They were packed and took a while to get our order. But it was worth it. The arancini and homemade meatballs took me back to Sicily ❤️. My boys loved the pizza and pepperoni roll. We will be back.

Serafina’s is such a hidden gem! Small with that cozy, welcoming vibe. The pizza was delicious with lots of options to choose from. We also had the mozzarella sticks with their red sauce.... it was SO good! As a fellow New Yorker, this place hit all the right notes. We’ll definitely be back!

I tried everything on the menu. Pizza 8/10. Calzone 4/10. Was cold in the middle and peppers were undercooked. Subs were fresh and delicious. 7/10.

This tiny gem off Race Track rd is worth stopping for!! We were trying to find a place for lunch, and stumbled onto Serafina's. We were NOT disappointed!! We ordered an 18" and the owner heard it was our first visit and to our surprise sent out an order of meatballs! My mom is super picky about meatballs and even picker about sauce, and she absolutely loved these and said the sauce was fantastic! The meatballs are generously portioned, sitting in a bed of tomato sauce that is made fresh, and has the perfect amount of garlic. Then our pizza came, it was delicious! The crust was crunchy without being tough, in fact it was tender while still somehow having the perfect chew! Finally we were surprised by zeppolle! Wow! How did they get them so light on the inside and crunchy on the outside? The

I genuinely don’t understand how this place has such great online reviews, because the food we got was terrible. We ordered a meat lover’s pizza and garlic knots, and both were honestly some of the worst we’ve ever tasted. The so-called “meat lover” pizza barely had any meat on it—just a few sad pieces scattered around (more of a pepperoni pizza)—and the rest was bland, greasy, and had an odd aftertaste that made us question if it was fully cooked. The garlic knots were dense, oily, and completely lacking flavor. What’s worse is that we felt sick shortly after eating, which should never happen from something as simple as pizza and garlic knots. I usually try to give places the benefit of the doubt, but this was such a bad experience that I can’t believe a pizza restaurant could serve food