Schultzy's Restaurant

3x is a charm! My husband and I are always seeking and traveling to various restaurants in search of excellence. Recently, we stumbled upon Schultzy’s in Bayville, NY. Well just Wow!!! This place is absolutely phenomenal. We have tried numerous dishes from the menu and the daily specials. Nothing has fallen short - food is incredible. We can’t say enough positives. And the staff has been amazing! The food is fresh flavorful and always hot! We have to give a huge shoutout about the desserts completely off the charts. This has quickly become my new favorite place to frequent. Kudos to the owner Jimmy - keep doing what you're doing truly top notch!!! **Dawn & Mike (Bellmore, NY)**

The owner Jimmy is a very nice guy! The food is awesome from the freshest oysters to the lobster rolls, baked clams are unforgettable!! They also have a good selection of wines and spirits.

I had a great light dinner there with my favorite type of food. A warm fresh baked roll, Lobster roll, little neck clams and beer. Service was great. The place is right but charming.

Found this place while looking for somewhere to go lunch and we love it! Everything was so good. Lobster Roll is 10/10 also the oyster is 10000/10 (especially when jimmy had to open every oyster for us XD) Love here

The interior is a bit small, but we arrived early so had no issue getting a table. The waitstaff was extremely attentive and friendly. I started with the shrimp allajillo appetizer which was savory. Make sure you get extra bread for dipping the sauce! For my entree I ordered the seafood fra Diavolo. I like mine extra spicy so I asked and they accommodated. It was filled with clams, mussels, shrimp and calamari. I almost couldn't finish it...almost! Very enjoyable meal, can't wait to return and try another dish.