Mill Creek Tavern

Bayville, NY · Restaurant

Rating
4.7/5
★★★★★ 4.7
Reviews
20
Rank in Bayville
#5
of 18 restaurants
City Percentile
53%
rating percentile
Address
Mill Creek Tavern, 275 Bayville Ave, Bayville, NY 11709
Phone
(516) 628-2000
Website
www.millcreekny.com
Status
Closed · Opens 4:30 PM

Mill Creek Tavern is a restaurant located in Bayville, NY. It is one of 18 restaurants listed in Bayville. Its 4.7-star rating is above the Bayville city average of 4.6 stars. It ranks #5 among Bayville restaurants by combined rating and review volume. There are 10 photos associated with this location.

About Mill Creek Tavern

Mill Creek is a favorite neighborhood restaurant in Bayville, NY, offering a relaxed yet casually elegant setting for seasonally inspired American cuisine. Our dinner menu features fresh, flavorful dishes and daily specials, enjoyed in both the... More

Hours

Saturday4 PM–10 PM

Customer Reviews

★★★★★ 5.0 KevinKelly · Mar 2026

First time here and honestly all the food is amazing from the meatball skillet and pretzel brie app to the Prime Rib special. The service from our waitress Jean was top notch. We will be back.

★★★★★ 5.0 Angelina Curcio · Feb 2026

Delicious celebration back in June but just got around to my review. Such a great deal on a delicious meal. The pork chops were so moist and tender and full of flavor. The lobster had a surprising white butter garlic sauce, I just wish I had asked for some Linguine to soak up the flavor.

★★★★★ 5.0 clkoenig · Feb 2026

We come here pretty often and always have a great meal and experience. Tonight we came for their mid-week fixed-price deal and it was good value. For $35 (with an upcharge for some entrees) each person gets an appetizer, entree and dessert. The dishes are slightly smaller versions of most of their regular menu items. I had the sautéed chicken entree and it was delicious as always. Definitely one of the highlights for us of coming to Mill Creek Tavern is seeing Jeanne. She’s a wonderful server and always personable and friendly. We’ll be back again soon!

★★★★★ 5.0 Danielle DeSanno · Feb 2026

I love the relaxing vibe at Mill Creek. Perfect spot for a comfort meal and good drinks. Their food is amazing (Mac and cheese is incredible) and the service is even better. Kathy is the absolute best! Girls night isn’t the same when she’s not there.

★★★★★ 5.0 Christopher Koenig · Feb 2026

Had the weekday Price fixed meal, starting with a buffalo spring roll (sorry forgot to take a pic) Yum! Then to this Lemon Sole Oreganata. The full price menu item is a bit larger, but the slightly smaller price fix plate doesn’t take away from the flavor of the dish. Just don’t expect take home leftovers. Well worth the price.

Accessibility & Amenities

✓ Wheelchair Accessible Entrance ✓ Wheelchair Accessible Parking Lot ✓ Wheelchair Accessible Restroom ✓ Wheelchair Accessible Seating

Services

RestaurantAmerican restaurantBarBar & grillCatererPasta shopPubSeafood restaurantSports barSteak house

Top Restaurants in Bayville

NameRatingReviews
Hidden Harbor Restaurant and Bar★★★★★ 4.920 reviews
Bayville Seafood★★★★★ 4.820 reviews
Schultzy's Restaurant★★★★★ 4.820 reviews
Talentis Delicatessen★★★★★ 4.720 reviews
Zozo's On The Bay★★★★★ 4.720 reviews
Totally Tubular★★★★★ 5.013 reviews
Sunset fish & lobster market & grill★★★★★ 4.620 reviews
Piccolo Cantina Bay★★★★★ 4.620 reviews
Chen’s Kitchen★★★★★ 4.520 reviews
Bayville Free Library★★★★★ 4.813 reviews

This listing is informational. Contact the business directly to verify credentials, services, and availability.