Sarah's Handmade Ice Cream Fallsgrove

Love, love, love me, some Sarah’s ice cream! Delicious flavors- one of my favorite salted caramel ice creams ever! So glad they have a location in Fallsgrove. Wonderful staff and always stocked with the all different kinds!

I can’t say enough great things about this ice cream shop! Their flavors are absolutely **out of this world**—rich, creamy, and packed with bold, authentic taste. What really sets them apart is their **organic, small-batch creations** that you simply can’t find anywhere else. Whether it’s a nostalgic classic with a twist or an inventive new combo, every scoop is pure perfection. The quality is unmatched, and you can tell they use **real, premium ingredients** without artificial shortcuts. If you’re looking for ice cream that’s **truly special**, this is the place. Do yourself a favor and stop by—your taste buds will thank you!

Always a great experience! The consistent taste is what keeps us coming back—always delicious and made with high-quality ingredients. We've visited all three locations and have been pleased every time. We absolutely love the Thai tea and black sesame flavors—they’re our favorites!

Sarah’s Handmade ice cream is so good that we’ve come twice in one week. I really love the Lavender Honey, Raspberry Chocolate Chip, and the Coconut Almond Brownie flavors. I also tried the Bailey’s Chocolate Chip and liked it as well. Also the staff are very friendly and welcoming. I’m glad we found this place. It’s a new favorite.

Really nice ice cream parlor with 30+ flavors, all locally sourced. Store was very clean and well kept. Ice cream itself was amazingly good. They had a lot of unique flavors like cherry blossom festival and Bailey's Irish chip. All were great with rich and smooth ice cream taste, so you cannot go wrong choosing a flavor.