Sal's Pizza Lake Alfred

We are new to the area and was looking for a new Italian spot. We stumbled on this place as it was down the road from our house. We ordered the meat lovers calzone, personal cheese pizza, and chicken parmigiana. We didn’t give it thought and ordered the large calzone. Hands down, the biggest calzone I have ever had! Servings are VERY generous and very reasonably priced. Amazing service. Definitely will be back!

Second time there and still outstanding. The taste was superb. Chicken Parmigiana and Manicotti very large portions and a great price. Highly recommend.

I love coming to grab pizza on a Friday night. The first time I came here I enjoyed the classic Italian art work and environment this place brings. On top of that the friendly staff makes you feel like family. What a cute little spot to stop in for a date night or new family spot! 😊🍕

Pizza was very good and they accepted cash for delivery which made it a big plus plus. The team member was new and was very helpful and friendly.

First time customer. Ordered large Sicilian meat lovers pizza for carry-out. 4pm on a Friday . They said 20 min.... It was ready in 20 min. Pizza was $30. It was huge. Could satisfy 6 normal appetites or 4 hearty ones... Probably with a little left over. Crust definitely Sicilian... Thick and risen++. Sauce generous, typical marinara. Cheese over the top plentiful. Meat toppings a little sparse but adequate. Probably could have used a few more minutes in the oven. It was tasty and I enjoyed it. Probably won't order the Sicilian crust again... A little to much. Next time will opt for the New York style... Which means I will go back again.