Calogero's Pizzeria

My husband and I were gifted a surprise date night by my parents, and Calogero's was the perfect place for it! We sat outside on their shaded patio, tucked away from the street for a peaceful ambiance. Everyone we spoke with was friendly, knowledgable, and clearly passionate about their food. We tried the meatballs, fettuccini, and vodka pasta dishes, and wrapped the evening splitting a piece of the pistachio cake. Everything was fresh, perfectly cooked, and tasted high-end. With the first bite, we were transported back to our Italian honeymoon! This place is a gem, and definitely worth repeating and trying new items. (We also ordered some of their wood fired pizzas as take out another time, and can vouch for the Margherita, Hot Honey, and Pepperoni pizzas, as well as their Greca salad!)

We’ve been going to Calogero’s in Lake Alfred since we first moved to Polk County! It has became our favorite spot for pizza in Polk County! Most of the time we get take out but we have also dined in several times. The pizza is wood fired and has always been delicious! The chocolate cake is amazing too! Do yourself a favor and check them out.

Came here with some coworkers after work today. Sooooooo pleased with the food, environment, and location. We came around 4pm and spot was empty. Looks like an evening spot. So glad we came at the time we did. Serving size was abundant. I ordered the greca salad and pizza of the day for Friday. Come check it out. Great spot and home style service!

I don’t usually leave reviews, but this was such a disappointing experience that I actually created a Google account just to warn others. This was my first—and definitely my last—time ordering from here through Uber Eats. I ordered two pizzas: • Funghi Pizza — advertised as having “wild mushrooms,” but it came with basic, plain mushrooms of only one type. • NY Cheese Pizza with added pepperoni — I paid an extra $2 for pepperoni, but the pizza arrived as a plain cheese pie. Both pizzas arrived cold (possibly Uber Eats’ fault, but still part of the overall bad experience). The real issue was the quality. Both pizzas were bland, barely had cheese, and whatever flavor might have been there was completely overpowered by the awful burnt taste of the crust. The entire bottom was black and charr

Amazing restaurant to get delicious food! We were visiting friends in the area and noone wanted to cook. Lol We were a group of 6 and sat at our table quickly. I ordered the personal size meat lovers pizza...which can easily feed 2! I loved the all natural ingredients, the pizza dough was so light and my stomach didn't leave with a heavy feeling...like when I eat most pizzas. The owner came around and was friendly with all the customers. He chatted with my brother and friends for a while, bringing on lots of laughter....remember us?! If you have never tried this restaurant, in Lake Alfred, you are missing out on great Italian food! Go see for yourself!💜