Rustoni’s Cafe

Recently stopped by this lovely café and had such a great experience. The service was exceptional, and Butch,the owner, was phenomenal. He truly took the time to make us feel welcome. I ordered the vanilla latte with maple praline cold foam and it was extremely delicious. We also tried the strawberry cheesecake crêpe, which was outstanding. I can’t wait to come back. Highly recommend this spot! Plus, there’s a pizza restaurant on the opposite side. So nice to finally have a charming coffee shop in Sayreville!

This was my first time at Rustoni's Cafe and I instantly fell for the atmosphere. The decor, the music, staff, and the owner all are great. The cappuccino and the Tiramisu were delicious. The owner Butch also made a delicious strawberry, banana, and Nutella crepe, fresh. Mouth watering!

The service here is awesome, obviously bc it’s Sayreville :), Their dessert and coffee menu is really really nice. We got the iced pumpkin spice maple cold foam latte and the iced caramel latte. Both were great. We were hesitant to get the cold brew but he offered us one to taste and it was genuinely one the best cold brews I’ve ever had. This is a relatively new place it used to be just a pizzeria, so that’s what you might know them for but don’t dismiss their coffee, it’s actually a really nice little cafe.

This new café is absolutely incredible! The hospitality and customer service are unmatched. Their gelato is some of the best I’ve ever had—rich, flavorful, and perfectly creamy. The lattes are just as amazing. It’s rare to find a place that combines such warm service with top-quality food and drinks. Definitely my new go-to spot!

Awesome atmosphere. Really 10/10 effort. Everyone is so friendly and welcoming! I hope this new cafe thrives because everything about it was just lovely! Beautiful vibes all around. I had a cranberry refresher, corn soup, and butternut squash raviolis. All were very tasty!