Prima Pizza of Colts Neck NJ

The service was excellent, and the pizza was absolutely delicious! You can really taste the difference with the fresh ingredients—the dough, sauce, and toppings were all so fresh and flavorful. I also loved the extended outdoor seating area; it’s a nice touch for enjoying your meal outside. The staff member who helped us was super friendly and accommodating, which made the experience even better. The only suggestion I have is about the lighting outside. Since it’s a bit dark in that area, especially with daylight savings time, adding a few more lights or signs would make it easier for drivers to spot the location and pull in safely. Overall, I had a great experience and will definitely be coming back!

i don't typically leave reviews, but i truly had such a wonderful experience at this little pizzeria. i decided to stop by for the first time for a quick lunch. i was immediately greeted so kindly by the family working the restaurant. they were extremely attentive and helpful, and gave me plenty of recommendations. i ended up deciding to get their upside down sicilian slice (delish!!) with an order of garlic knots. they even gave me a garlic knot to snack on while i waited for my food. truly such a kind family running this business. the food was great and the service was excellent. they told me i'd be back, and i definitely believe that to be true ! great new find 😊

My GO TO place for a few slices! Nick & Johnny are as friendly & accommodating as all the reviews say they are. The ingredients in their pizza are high-quality. I like well done slices that don’t flop down when you hold them out. Nowhere does that better than Prima!

Delicious food, always very fresh & made with love just like home made. Owner John is very friendly and courteous. Our new go to place. Thank you John. You are a great addition to our local community. I highly recommend for everyone to try this restaurant.

Was in Colts Neck and had a craving for pizza. Found this place through a Google search and saw it had great reviews. This place did not disappoint. We got the margherita pie and it was delicious. The sauce was amazing and the crust was just right. They have great sauce and dough. The owner and the guy working the front were really nice and helpful. I will definitely come back for more of their delicious pizza next time I’m in Colts Neck.