Potito's Bakery

When I arrived, the display cases were mostly empty. I was told that the baker "won't be back for a few days." I should have left then. It cost me $7.50 for a half dozen, day old (at least a day old, maybe more), donuts. I chose a ricotta filled powdered donut to have with my morning coffee. The ricotta was too sweet and the pastry was bordering on inedibly stale. I've been here before and had a good experience, so I will try again in the future. Next time, however, I will ask when the pastries were made before making any purchases. I would have given a lower rating, but the employee was bright and cheerful, in spite of the early hour and dismal weather.

Awesome donuts when they’re fresh. Most days anymore they seem day old and clearly not fresh. Depends on the day you go I guess. Fresh day, 5 stars; stale day, 2 stars. Overall, 3 stars. At $18 a dozen, my wife rode her bike in the rain to get them I was excited for a delicious fresh donut with my fresh coffee I made - today is a 2 star donut day. 🙁

Tasted stale and old doughnuts!!! We were so excited to grab doughnuts for our first weekend at the shore. They were absolutely horrible and tasted like day old doughnuts. I actually called to ask if they were day old and was told that they were fresh baked overnight. If this is the product they are selling as fresh, I will never return. I will feed them to the birds. Very disappointing to say the least. Run!

Sorry Potito’s! Your donuts were not baked the day I bought them and shouldn’t have been sold as fresh baked. The cannoli was mediocre. The raspberry crumb cake saved you though. That was delicious. Slightly disappointed. Won’t be returning anytime soon. Nothing like Ritner Street.

Had a family party on the beach Sunday. We pre-ordered two crumb cakes (one regular, one raspberry) and a tray of brownies. Ordering and pick up was super easy! Very friendly staff. The desserts were delicious and perfect for sitting in the beach. Everyone enjoyed it.