Potbelly

I’ll admit it—I would never have stopped here on my own because the name Potbelly Sandwich Shop sounds like pure carnivorous hog heaven… and it’s absolutely not that. Surprise of the day: this is actually a solid, thoughtfully done sandwich spot with vegetarian options and easy vegan modifications. They offer salads, pickles, good bread choices, and even the option to scoop out the inside of the bread for a lighter, veggie-forward bite (which I appreciated). Service was great, the space felt welcoming, and I loved seeing their community wall and family-friendly initiatives like kids-eat-free days. Honestly, it makes Subway look pretty rough by comparison. The name is wildly deceiving, but the experience was genuinely better than expected—and I’m glad someone else convinced me to walk in.

I had a truly delicious, fresh, and thoughtfully made sandwich. It’s been a while since I’ve had one this good. Thank you for the kind and wonderful service!

This used to be my favorite sandwich shop. I ordered three sandwiches this evening through the app which I’m pretty proficient with. I am familiar that and select new things. I went and made an order and I looked at it with a fine tooth comb. I ordered three sandwiches with all of the vegetables and they put the wrong kind of cheese. I get home and none of the sandwiches have any vegetables. I called the shop And let them know and they said on their end it didn’t show vegetables. I know what I ordered. I’ve done it plenty of times with this particular sandwich shop. They did not offer any. Also not happy with their customer. Very unsatisfactory. I am disappointed.

Staff awesome, sandwich was drenched in mayo, the sandwich was wrapped and 1/4 of the sandwich was fully covered in mayo and could see it even through the white paper it was wrapped in, would have been a good sandwich if it hadn't been for that. I could only eat half. Fresh ingredients. I'm sure next time will be better. Will update if so

This restaurant really caught me by surprise. I had see it driving up and down Broadway but never thought about visiting. Well I'm really sad it took so long to visit. The store looks charming and the food was great. Was suggested the Turkey Club from the most friendly employee as a first time and paid it with some Broccoli Cheese soup. I plan on going back in again as soon as possible!