Pontillo's Pizzeria

Outstanding pizza! The crust was light and crispy, and the ricotta tasted incredibly fresh. Definitely recommend giving it a try.

I grew up in Greece. Worked for a pontillos that was near the mall. I have bought pizza from this place here in spencerport since 2006. Tonight a mishap happened. As a business owner myself I understand mistakes happen. We are human after all. They corrected the issue extremely fast I was very happy about that. Wasn't expecting anything else but it was a nice gesture for sure. Pontillos does a great job and will clearly continue seeing my order. Thank you for the stellar service at all points even during mishaps. Happy new year and if I could give 10 stars I would. Great service, great people, great reputation, great follow through.

If this is what you call extra thick crust, you are stealing money from your customers. This is thin crust at best. If we were not hungry I would have brought it back. I can not believe you actually sent this out of the kitchen.

This place has quickly become a weekly staple for me. The pizzas are always a 10, and the steak subs are a new favorite of mine. Every worker goes above and beyond and I appreciate that the owner is very hands on, his love for his business shows not only in his food, but in the treatment of his customers. Highly recommended!

First I'd like to say we are fans of your slices. We had family over for football on Sunday and ordered a sheet pizza and wings. The wings were awesome. The pizza we were disappointed. We paid almost $4.00 for each topping. The topping were not plentiful at all. The pizza was under cooked and dry. We will continue to buy our slices from you. Just wanted to give a little feedback. Employees are awesome.