Plum Tomato Pizzeria & Restaurant

I’ve been eating from Plum my entire life. Pizzas, sandwiches, subs, pastas, dinner entrees. My father and I would often share a whole chicken parm sub. He also loved the meatball sub, their sicilian, and spaghetti with meat sauce. We even had it on what would be his last birthday, 12/18/24. He died of cancer last month and Plum pizza was the last meal he ever had, and we ate it together.

To get me out of a bind, I decided to go for pizza. We went there because we had tried them once at a children's event in the park. I ordered by phone, a medium pizza, half margherita and half plain. Unfortunately, I ordered it wrong! And they made me 2 medium pizzas. Despite my mistake, they weren't angry; they very kindly asked if I wanted both, and I said no, it was too much because only my kids would be eating. So they gave me the other pizza for free! What for someone might be a minor thing, for others is a huge blessing when you're a busy mom of four. Besides, one pizza wouldn't have been enough since they devoured them, and I even got to try three slices! Thank you so much, Plum Tomato. God bless you...

I went to get veg pizza slices as I like to have pizza slices often and keep trying different stores. This time I ended up going to Plum Tomato but it was 30 minutes before closure like around 9:30 Pm and it gets closed by 10:00PM . I was told that they take last order by 9:45Pm and I ended up taking 2 pizza slices. It looked delicious but when I tried one slice was chewy and not soft. Its sides are very hard so it felt like I should not have taken this slice and not worth with amount paid tastewise. Another slice was soft , which was veg slices, and better than previous one. However, taste was just fine comparative to other stores. I would give store 3 stars based on its taste of slices. It was my first time here, I would try again next time and if it find it better , I would update my

Truly the best food. My husband is from Brooklyn, so he's very particular about his pizza. Plum Tomato is the ONLY nearby location to us that even comes close to good, flavor-filled pizza. The staff is super friendly, and we know each other by name. It feels like an extended family. Their specialty pans are especially delicious. Definitely try them out of you're in the area.

Rahway’s Best-Kept Food Secret 🍤🍕 Plum Tomato has a secret menu item I’ve been ordering for years: Fried butterfly shrimp, cooked dark, with spicy or regular marinara on the side. 🔥 It’s not on the menu — but trust me, it’s one of the best things they make. I’ve been coming here for over 5 years, and the food is always on point. No place in Rahway, Colonia, Linden, Westfield, or Clark touches this spot when it comes to pizza, either. Huge shoutout to the owners, the cooks, the ladies up front who always take care of my order, and the delivery drivers who keep it all moving. This place is a gem — family-run feel, consistent food, and real local pride. If you know, you know. If you don’t… now you do.