Pizzas By Marchelloni - New Castle

NY Pizza is hard to come by, but with Marchellonies you get exactly that. I heard a story about a guy who was from NY but didn't like Marchellonies, he's not from NY clearly. Great work over there Marchellonies. We love it. You tell them other NY guys to come see me so we can talk about it. Open late Wing Accommodations Close to center New Castle. Highly Recommended.

Excellent Pizza!! Really, really tasty crust, sauce and cheese. Awesome prices too. Building is nothing at all, but the food is great!!!! Friendly staff too.

I always get the gluten-free pizza. They use a cauliflower crust, which I hadn't been able to find after Pizza Joe's discontinued theirs. Always good. Food is ready fast after ordering.

I came here for the first time and it was also the last time. The staff is rude and unfriendly. The shop is filthy with nowhere to sit and wait. They’d fail a health inspection easily. The pizza was atrocious, so much sauce cascading out of cheese that was like glue. It gave me serious indigestion and acid reflux. Will never come back to this awful pizza shop.

I live in Ellwood City where there are many good pizza parlors. I indulge in them often and enjoy them thoroughly. That being said, any time I know I will be traveling to New Castle, I always call Marchelloni for an extra large pizza with bacon! It’s the absolute best pizza in my humble opinion. I will have you know though, I am somewhat of a pizza carnisaur, with 47 years of pizza devouring experience🤣! Seriously though, this is my favorite pizza anywhere, and I have met the owner and he is such a wonderful person, truly deserving of your patronage.