Two Fat Guys and an Oven

This is a must stop if you are in the area!! The breakfast sandwiches were yummy and were made with their homemade roll! The pizza was just delicious, the dough, the sauce…everything about it. The spinach/cheese roll was so good! The rye bread was also yummy! Delicious bakery and pizza place! Everyone working there was friendly. Service is great! Definitely a cute spot!! I did see they do alot of christmas cookie orders too! The cookies looked out of this world!

I absolutely adore Two Fat Guys & an Oven. It’s the best place to get something sweet in New Castle. They always have a variety of pastries to choose from - I’ve never had one I didn’t enjoy. My favorites are the cherry & cheese danish, the pistachio cannolis (they have lots of great flavors tho), and my absolute favorite is the chocolate dipped CARAMEL APPLES. I have truly never had a better caramel apple in my life. The caramel is incredibly soft and the apple also seemed just much more juicy. I’ve only seen them in the bakery once, but really hope it becomes a more reoccurring staple. I’m not a pizza gal, but I also love their pizza. The owners and the staff are always extremely friendly.

I love their pastries and their food dishes for lunch. The pastries are amazing and for fair prices especially cause the size of them. Always freshly baked and have something I want. Great place to eat or get some breakfast pastries for the office or home for the family. Just an all around great choice.

The nicest staff with a great selection of baked goods, cookies, pastries, breads, soups and even pizza! We found everything to be tasty, fresh and delicious - especially the chocolate peanut butter cannoli!

What an amazing place & staff. We stopped in for some pastry treats and decided to have brunch. We ate a Sfaglatelle, our first time trying this and it was delicious. Crispy & crunchy layers of phyllo wrapped around flavorful ricotta. We took a full bag of goodies after that! The owner also offered to make my wife a fresh Stromboli (we were a little early for lunch) and offered us a free brownie!! We were so impressed and will be back for sure!