Pizzaiolo Gourmet Eatery

My husband willingly drives from Queens to Commack just for Pizzaiola — which is wild, because he won’t even drive across the street for most things. The second he walks in with that box, our dogs lose their minds. My senior pup has early doggie dementia, and even he suddenly remembers his life mission: follow the pizza box and make tiny beep noises until someone gives him a slice. If that’s not a miracle, I don’t know what is. According to my husband, Dominic and Will aren’t just good — they’re legendary. This isn’t customer service; this is hospitality with superpowers. 10/10. Worth the miles, the barking, and the beeping.

They are awesome!! I ordered from them for my Grand Opening and everyone kept saying how great the food was. I even had a client call back and ask where the food was from. Definitely recommend!! Nutella pie was also a crowd pleaser. I had my desserts cancel on me last minute. I called them to add onto my order. The fruit was so fresh!!! Sandwich platter, wraps, Nutella pie and more. They did amazing.

I usually order a whole pie for dinner but this I decided to change it up. I ordered a tray of chicken parm with vodka sauce and it was amazing, definitely ordering again! :)

The best and most consistent pizza in the Commack area. The toasted breadcrumb crust, so so good. Key ingredients are second to none. I recommend well done.

AMAZING selection of specialty slices and pies, service was quick and pleasant. Crispy crust and excellent flavor! Definitely try the buffalo chicken garlic knots, they are to die for!!!