Pizza Pit - Lake Mills

Pizza in a little under cooked missing 1 of the ingredients. The pizza has good flavor. Please the food was done very fast

I grew up in lake mills. Since then, I’ve lived in New York, Pennsylvania, Minnesota, Illinois, and Texas. I’ve been around. But tonight, after yet another disappointing pizza, I thought fondly, as I always do, of Pizza Pit. No one will ever make a pizza the way they do. It is the best. I tell my wife, one day we will return to my hometown and you can experience pizza the way god intended it. I often check the Pizza Pit google page, in fear that they may close before I can return.

Such a cute little shop! Pizza was fresh and serviced was friendly

Unfortunately the last few times the food has been flavorless and my order was missing items that I paid extra for. This used to be one of my favorite pizza places in the area. I always ask for extra sauce on my pizza and this time instead I get a bucket of cheese and a soggy plain pizza. The gyros used to be good too but this time weren't and the fries were also very bland and soggy. To me it seems like the prices keep going up and yet the quality is going down. The only positive is the delivery drivers are always polite and fast, but sadly that isnt enough to save this review from 1 star. I will not be a returning customer and will instead find another place to give my business to. Do better Pizza Pit.

Im not sure what has happened to this place. Ordered pizza tonight and the pizza was raw ! Called and wanted my money back, they offered to make a new one ,I took the bait. The second one wasn't much better, at least we could eat the outer perimeter. I really hope they can figure out what's happening.