Piece of Cake

They absolutely crushed it. From beginning to end, from tasting to the day of the wedding, they didn’t leave anything to chance and made cupcakes and a wedding cake that not only looked incredible, but tasted even better (I didn’t realize it was possible either). They helped make our wedding day the best day of our lives and I want to order again and again just to eat the delectable cupcakes. I’d give them 100 stars if I could!!!

Judy and her team not only created little works of art for our baby shower, but she also made delicious cupcakes that everyone could not stop talking about! We chose chocolate with raspberry filling and vanilla with strawberry filling, and the cakes were moist and delicious, and the filling was just the right amount of sweetness! Absolute perfection!

We got married at Pinehills Golf Club in June 2025 and that is how we found Piece of Cake. Judy was so friendly and was amazing to work with! We loved being able to test different flavors and having the option to pick multiple flavors of cupcakes. She offers such a great variety and each of them is so delicious. Each cupcake is so pretty and it made a beautiful display at our wedding. Judy was understanding about what we wanted for the design of our wedding cake and it came out better than we imagined, and so yummy too! Our guests loved the cupcakes so much there were only 2 left at the end of the night! They were a big hit!

Amazing service!! I must have inquired with 12 bakeries for a gender reveal and cupcakes. Every single one either didn’t get back to me or wouldn’t have had it for me for 2 weeks - months out! Piece of cake so was easy to work with and got back to me immediately. They are reasonably priced unlike others. $100 for a heart shaped cake (8-10 servings) and a dozen gender reveal cupcakes with similar style to the cake. It was so special! They did pink frosting and strawberry filling just like I asked. And they had it ready for me the NEXT DAY 🩷 it was also the best tasting cake I’ve ever had. Amazing service I love this business I can’t wait to use them in the future!

Piece of Cake is the absolute best for custom orders! We have worked with them many times over the years, both at their initial location and at their long-term home on Westerly Road. Most recently, we needed a special cake for a 10-year-old who is obsessed with Wednesday Addams, and they delivered a masterpiece. The gorgeous purple and black design was exactly what we envisioned. Creepy. Kooky. Mysterious. Spooky. Delicious. Beyond the aesthetics, the customer care here is what truly stands out. We were struggling to choose a topper, and they generously offered detailed, professional advice about which third-party options have poor quality (saving us a lot of trouble!). Despite being slammed with orders, they were extremely flexible, letting us drop off our final decorations just a coup