Pie Society

Lived down south for a while and decided to finally pop in here… Emma was very pleasant and sweet. We picked small smaller tarts.. not bad…. TheApple Pie though - Yikes. Check out how much cinnamon overkill it’s sitting in.. sorry .. this is not a proper British Apple Pie. Kitchen knows it overdid it with the cinnamon- yet still baked those pies with that much cinnamon? Not ok for $15 -1/2pie. Too dark Best of luck.

Enjoyed lunch the Friday of Labor Day at 12:15 and it was packed! Only a few minutes to get a table, but food and service took a bit too long. Nice quaint atmosphere. My savory pie of beef and mushrooms was pretty good. Hubby enjoyed fish and chips. Little pricey but a nice treat to meet an old friend for lunch! Our first visit since the big change. Really special! Shortbread cookies are delicious!!

We picked up a whole American apple pie (with cinnamon), in the past these have been great, unfortunately this wasn’t our experience this time. The woman working the counter wasn’t the nicest, I get it, we walked in 10 minutes before close, but she made it seem as though our visit was an inconvenience. In previous visits the pies have been great, I’m fond of the banoffee and the savory pies as well. This pie was clearly burnt. The burnt crust really impacted the overall flavor of the pie. I think we’ll be taking a break from here for a while. Bummer.

$6 per portion for these chips, and this what we received… Absolutely disgraceful value for money. And the quality of the chips were much poorer than previous visits. Very disappointing.

I have eaten at Pie Society several times and loved it! At work we have had an employee have surgery and an employee's spouse have surgery. I ordered pies and deserts for both employees. When I placed the ordered I ordered them cold so that when the employee was ready to cook them when they were ready and the meal would be hot. Both employees raved at what a good idea ordering from Pie Society was one even said that he was going to start picking up pies on his way home. This is a great place and the people who work there are so friendly and accommodating.