Pie Lovers

Wonderful atmosphere, customer service, and pies! We've tried quite a few flavors, the coconut cream pie is our favorite. The crust is thick but bakes perfectly and the crust/filling ratio is good. The pies are heavy, you can tell they do not skip on ingredients (we had the pecan pie once and there were SO many pecans!). I wish they had a customer loyalty card so we could afford to go more often :)

I could cry at how wonderful these people and this place is. I bought just about every mini pie available and the chocolate pecan pie for my sisters birthday. Best pie I have had in a long time. It’s so refreshing enjoying a family business like this. The empanadas were fantastic as well. 10/10.

So glad I’ve discovered this hidden gem. Pies are delicious, original, and adorably decorated. For awhile I’d only tried their sweet pies, but I recently got a discounted chicken pot pie and I’m SO SAD I didn’t try the savory pies sooner. I’m from Lancaster county, and the Amish make the best savory pies, so I have very high standards but this was great. Can’t wait to try their quiche next. I also love that it seems to be family owned!

Stopped in and picked out empanadas,, rice pudding, and a 1/2 dozen mini pies to go. The empanadas were excellent, I tried both chicken and beef. For the pie I got classic pecan, pecan bourbon, amd apple and they were wonderful. The rice pudding was the best I can remember having. The people working there were helpful amd friends. I will certainly be back for more goodies!

I have purchased about 6 pies from here, every one of them were DELICIOUS. They were all taken as a hostess gift for a dinner party, every time it was "omg DELICIOUS, yuuuummmmm, incredible". I definitely recommend.