Pickleman's Gourmet Cafe - O'Fallon, MO

I used to get lunch here once a week and loved this place but have since moved 30 minutes away. I decided to get lunch there today because I missed it and was shocked to see one measly piece of ham on my sandwich, hardly any toppings and the bread was really hard. Then I see all of the reviews complaining about the same exact thing at this location. Picklemans responding to these reviews saying they are sorry but what are you really doing about it??? I will take my business to Goodcents since their bread, meat, and portions are way better anyway.

I really want to like Pickleman’s, but the value just isn’t there. The portions are too small for the prices being charged. It often feels like I’m paying mostly for bread with minimal toppings or fillings, which doesn’t justify the cost. I’m not writing this to criticize for the sake of it, but to bring this concern to corporate attention. Pickleman’s has a great concept and quality ingredients, but the portion-to-price ratio makes it hard to feel satisfied as a customer. If corporate takes this feedback seriously and adjusts portion sizes to match the prices, I believe many customers, myself included, would gladly return and recommend Pickleman’s to others.

We wanted to try something different than the standard places and it was ok. They do offer salads and I think items other than subs but I recommend looking online for them as you can only read patr of the menu in store. They use large electronic displays but you have to order at the rest of the super and one of the displays is his high above and behind the oven exhaust fan. You can't read it. Everything seems backwards and blocked. I ordered the regular Italian and it was good. My wife had the half turkey and it was small! The staff did point out that it is a very small sandwich. Maybe 3 inches long. A regular is only slightly bigger than a half subway for comparison. Price is reasonable and they do offer a military discount. Thanks for doing that. Also, they're is availa

Always delicious..best tuna fish salad in town. Can you do a special like every other month for a weekly special on this, similar to the meatball sub you did before Lent? Thank you so much for making the perfect tuna fish salad!!

My husband stopped to pick up lunch & ordered me the chicken asiago half sandwich. There was hardly anything on the sandwich & only 4 inches when it's supposed to he a 6 inch. Very disappointing. Don't even want to eat it. Waste of money