Pi Pizzeria

The food was very good! Atmosphere was quite cozy & friendly but was on the loud side. I realize that is hard to control but just saying. Had a great chat with our neighbor at the next table. Would definitely return.

I recently had the pleasure of dining at a charming little pizza place on Nantucket, and it was truly a delightful experience. The cozy atmosphere immediately made me feel at home, and the intimate setting added to the overall charm. Now, let's talk about the star of the show—the pizza. Cooked in a wood-fired oven, it had that unmistakable smoky flavor that only comes from such traditional cooking methods. The crust was perfectly crispy on the outside, yet wonderfully chewy on the inside. Each bite was a symphony of flavors, from the tangy tomato sauce to the melty cheese and the delectable toppings. It was undoubtedly one of the best pizzas I've ever had. When on Nantucket it’s a must visit.

This place is the bomb so that being said summertime it’s crazy. Even spring and fall are busy! Been here dozens of times if you like Italian food, I highly recommend it treat yourself to an awesome meal! Believe me, I have tried almost everything on their menu it’s awesome. Just give them a little patience when it’s super busy, thank you PI Pizzeria!

Pizza was okay, but have a few complaints. First when we walked in we said hello to the bartender who just gave us a dirty look without saying anything. Then the hostess/waitress came up and she was nice but very quiet. We ordered a pizza, meatballs and garlic bread. The meatballs were tasty but for $16 3 tiny meatballs does not cut it especially when the meatball sub comes with 6 for $1 less. The garlic bread was priced at $7 on the menu but we were charged $8 and it was only partially seasoned with garlic and butter. The pizza was good but the crust was definitely passed the point of being well done and was actually burnt. Also adding pepperoni each slice had less than 1 actual pepperoni cut into strips. With how many amazing food options there are on the island there's really no point

Very quick and friendly service. The pepperoni pizza was great. We also got the Sicilian sub, which was good, but definitely could've used a bit more meat or at least a thinner bread. Overall, we enjoyed our time.