Pauly's NY Pizza & Ice Cream

I ordered the Extreme Pepperoni pizza. Some places say “extreme,” but Pauly’s truly means it! The prices might be a little higher than some sub shops, but this is definitely a case of getting what you pay for, & is worth the little bit extra! Everything here is absolutely delicious. Bonus: the milkshakes are on par with Dumser’s!

Best New York pizza I’ve ever had and it’s right here in our backyard. Everyone should be so lucky to have such a great pizza place that delivers on time and exactly what you ordered with a smile it surely made our day and our event. Thank you so much Pauly’s pizza!

Tried a 10-inch cheese pie recently. The crust was thin and crispy—not bad, just not the classic New York style I grew up with. If you're looking for that chewy, foldable slice, this isn’t it. That said, the overall quality was decent. The cheese and sauce did their job, and while nothing stood out as amazing, it was at least an average pie. Not bad for a casual bite, but not quite what I'd reach for when craving a true NYC slice.

The pepperoni pizza was satisfactory. However, the Mellow Mushroom pizza had an excessive amount of mushrooms, making it less palatable. It is important to note that all the pizzas appear to have unusually generous toppings. Update: The cheesesteak sub was surprisingly great. The only complaint I would have is a little too much mayo. I also liked the ground beef and bacon that was on the cheeseburger pizza. I did not care for the thousand island dressing. My wife enjoyed her cheese pizza.

This is such a gem for anything you could ever want from a pizza and sub shop. The Italian Hoagie is amazing, easily one of the best in the region. Pizza is very good as well, but an unsung hero is the Ribeye Panini. That thing is incredible. Gravy fries are too notch too. Looking forward to trying other menu items in the future.