Paulie's Pizza and Wings

Fair price amazing pizza with thin crust very much New York style. The staff is very accommodating and nice. They also deliver minimum $15 which is great instead of going to Uber eats or DoorDash. Highly recommended.

Absolutely fantastic experience! Since coming under new management, this pizzeria has truly flourished. The food is amazing — fresh, flavorful, and perfectly prepared every time. The service is just as impressive — friendly, attentive, and welcoming. You can really see the positive changes. Highly recommend

The best pizza and the best service , everyone here is so welcoming and warm and I have done Too Good To Go and they are generous and fair and I have also brought dishes here because they are delicious and good pricing !! A hidden gem in Tenafly!! When Pizza makers love what they do it translates in the food ...yum😋😋 And they habe street fighter..my lottle guy loves it here!

The wrong order was delivered to me and I was only refunded for half of what I paid. The wings were also very small and not the garlic parm ones I ordered, but very spicy ones..I can't eat very spicy food. I took a bite hoping they would at least be mild, but they were not. The calzone was cold and not very tasty. The manager said he was the only one working that night...well if that's the case then I'm sorry but don't take orders if you're so busy that you get an entire order wrong. Also, at least refund the person the full wrong order. Edit- I contacted the restaurant and they said their response to make things right was automated and they still did not refund me in full...what a joke lol. Don't order from here, much better food around anyway.

I love this place, their pizza is amazing! Daisy and Gio were both super helpful and friendly. This is our new favorite pizza spot in the neighborhood and will be coming back very soon!