Papa Johns Pizza

If I could give them no stars I would! I ordered through the phone and the gentleman was so nice and helpful with deals. I went in store to pick up my order and realized I forgot to order a second pizza that I wanted which I thought would just be added to my order so I paid. I gave them time went home and came back for pickup of my second pizza for them to accuse me running out and not paying. I had also asked was it not required for them to wear gloves when handling/making food and it’s not a requirement but I told them that they didn’t have to be unsanitary. I wish I was treated better as a customer because an employee named Jackie and one of the males started to try and go back and forth with me as I was trying to figure out why this wasn’t explained to me.

This place has become terrible. To top it all off, witnessed an event where it was busy, and they didnt get this persons order done they place early in the day and it wasnt even close. This has happened to us as well. The Papa Johns employee was very rude and disrespectful, the manager was only a little better. We've seen issues with this manager before as well. We're gonna stop going here and sticking with others in the area who are much more respectful to their customers... I dont know how this guy kept his cool like he did with the employees there...

Stopped by today an it smells so good an I must say to the manager for the Halloween display absolutely love it. Was good to see great spookies :) employee was so nice that I spoke to. Glad to see good ppl still exist. Xo Lava

In Hurricane once a year for a week long conference and always look forward to visiting Papa Johns on our first night here. Food is excellent and fast & friendly service. Will visit them several times this week for dinner.

They stopped giving plates and the workers were rude about it. I also paid for extra cheese on my pizza but there was a thin layer, definitely not extra cheese. They didn’t cut the pizza adequately either. For the price, I’d recommend a local place like Gino’s, or if that’s not your dish, it’s worth making the drive to Domino’s in Eleanor. Papa John’s is more expensive than both of those restaurants but they do a solid job every time. I regret that I didn’t go there instead but I forgot that Papa John’s is like this and I used to love eating there!