Papa Johns Pizza

This is the first time in years that I had a delivery go wonderfully. The order was delivered hot and correct. I had all my sauces, the correct 2 liter and the pizza was perfectly round with a beautiful crust. The bread sticks were ALL soft and fluffy. The cheese sticks had cheese throughout and not burnt. The pizza was topped evenly with a great balance of crust. I was so amazed at this extremely satisfying meal, I had to post the good news. Great job! (This time)

I don't usually eat chain pizza. But sometimes It's just quick and easier. I haven't had Papa John's in maybe 20 years. Last night I got one of their "New" pan Pizzas. While it was easy to order online and pick up with no problems, the pizza was TERRIBLE. It was cold and it was tough and dry. Like it had been sitting in a box for a couple hours. Chain pizza is cheap for a reason, but you kinda expect it at least not to be old and at least warm. I won't be returning.

I came back after 4 years to change my feedback. I will not be trying it again. The last 3 times that I've ordered have been terrible. The pizzas always have a ridiculously sized crust that is extremely thin in the center, with all of the toppings piled in the middle. It is disappointing to say the least :/

Boneless wings had enough sauce to cover 1/3 of the wings and were like chicken nuggets.

This location sucks. Papa Johns is overpriced anyway, but I have not had a single order with this store go normally. I had a carryout order around a year ago where they gave my pizza to someone else, so I had to wait an additional twenty minutes at the store. Not a sorry or an excuse offered. Ordered delivery tonight, and their tracker marked delivered. It was not, and when I called, I was told my phone number was disconnected, and my apartment number was not on the order. Two issues I have never had ordering from any other place in Fairmont. Get pizza literally anywhere else in town.