Pagliai's Pizza

Heard good things about Pagliai's Pizza and decided to make the hour-long drive. It was absolutely worth it! The pizza reminds us of Northern Italy, and the service and atmosphere were excellent. Highly recommended.

Road trip, stopped here for pizza. Thin crust sausage and pepperoni was AWESOME, house salad great. Place was packed but I got in immediately and served quick. Great ingredients on the pizza, its taste was the best part. This place is a gem, I wish it were local to me.

Place is awesome. Food is great if you are looking for great pizza you need to try this place evan if you are just passing through the area.

Decided to try sandwiches this time since the last couple pizzas we had ordered seemed overly greasy. Placed takeout order with friendly helpful employee, and was greeted upon entering by another friendly employee. Got food home and the chips were soggy from being put in styrofoam with a hot sandwich. Italian panini was spewing grease like an erupting volcano, and husband said meatball sandwich was like chewing a sawdust covered cardboard box. As always the ranch dressing was impeccable though. Definitely not worthy of the $34 price tag this time.

While I have always bragged this is great pizza, tonight was terrible. Cheese bread was cold and soggy. The crust of the pizza was so tough you couldn't bite it, we had to tear it. The cheese was so overcooked it didn't even pull apart and was burnt about 2 inches in all the way around the edges. I always order beef instead of sausage because I can't have the spicyness of italian sausage. The "beef" was so spicy you couldn't even taste the pepperoni. $28 for a 14" pizza and over 1/2 of it had to be thrown away. Very dissapointed