Orr Valley Creamery

We are heading home back to Tennessee and I didn’t eat yet today, was super hangry and I saw this place and decided to try it as I wasn’t feeling subway and we like to try mom and pop shops. I am really happy we decided to try this place! I can’t believe they carry custard from Sarasota Florida!?!? I grew up and spent 38 yrs in Florida before moving to Tennessee 7 years ago. Their coney dogs were delicious, their coney sauce is more like manwich than chili sauce, it worked really well with the dogs. Also, they toast their buns and the hotdogs themselves were delicious. I got the coney fries as a side. They were tasty as well. We ate first then ordered to concrete mix ins, I had the royal crunch and my husband had the mint magic. Both were delicious!!

Great service with a smile! Marilyn, Caitlyn, Hudson and Quinn all contributed to our amazing experience! Thanks for a great season at the Wooster location!

Great ice cream place! Good selection of ice cream and custards. They have other food as well but I've never tried it so can't rate that.

The ice cream was excellent! Our server Jamee was fantastic and helped guide us to a great treat! Cost was a bit on the expensive side but overall it was a good experience!

I had the Reuben dog. It was so good I could have at least two or three more and concrete mix was so good.