Original Italian Pizza

This is officially my favorite pizza shop, I think ever. Im newer to the area and have been looking for a quality shop that had good pie, subs and cheesesteaks. I've found a few that are pretty good, but nowhere compares to the Milton OIP.. I know OIP is a common name, but this one is by far the best ive ever eaten at. Not only is the food fantastic, but the owner, Mario is a super nice, friendly person. It only took one time and one conversation for me to feel like a truly valued customer. The 2nd time I was ever in there, I was greeted by my first name and asked how my day is. That is a lost art these days and very rarely seen anymore.i dont know them that well, but I already consider them friends! Now to the food. The absolute best marinara/pizza sauce ive ever had. Its simpl

Just ordered 12/20/25, the chicken bacon ranch is super good and the prices are good for the size of what you are getting.

I have asked multiple times for well done pizza. I even asked if they knew what well done was. They said yes after I said it means to cook it longer. After multiple times I've never gotten well done and in fact have gotten the opposite. I don't like doughy pizza, maybe people like it but I'm not a fan. Just listen it's not difficult. Not one thing cooked well done.

What a great lunch spot I stumbled into while passing through town. Incredibly fresh bread for my delicious chicken parm sandwich. Good salad. Great service and great chatting with Mario!

By Far the best steak sandwich I have ever had. They make the sandwich bread it was a must stop if traveling 80 in PA. I have eaten alot of restaurants this is one of the best.