Orange Hill Restaurant, Newburgh, NY

We stopped by at Orange Hill Restaurant on our way to our upstate destination by chance. I have not been this pleasantly suprised by a spot ever. We ordered steak, lamb rack and a salad. When the food arrived the presentation looked like someone put a lot of care into it albeit somewhat cozy old fashioned. But then every bite tasted so amazing. The service staff was so polite and attentive. The prices for what we got in terms of the flavor and the quality was so good. I think even not on a road trip this place is worth the drive. I know my review is above and beyond positive. But I promise its not a fake review. Amazing suprise!

We have dined here twice, and each time has been terrific! The service is prompt and attentive without being invasive. The wine is good and a nice size pour. We have had the cauliflower and warm caprese appetizers, and wow, they do not disappoint!! Among the three of us, we have had the salmon, mango chicken, lamb chops, and chicken Milanese for dinners. All have been prepared very well, tasted delicious, and the presentation is artful and visually pleasing. These dishes all had a great amount of flavor and the portion size is generous. Across our two visits, we have had the crème brûlée trio, affogato, cappuccino ice cream, and poached pears for dessert. So. Much. Flavor!!!! The ambiance is nice, with a fireplace in one room, comfortable chairs, and tasteful decor. Prices are reasonable.

Excellent restaurant that deceivingly looks like a diner from the outside, but the atmosphere and service are anything but on the inside. The food was excellent. I highly recommend the cauliflower critters and bacon brussel sprouts for appetizers. The salmon, steak and risotto were all amazing. The desserts were also wonderful, and we had some great drinks. I will definitely come back, this is now one of my favorites in Newburgh, for sure.

Had a great experience at Orange Hill, and a big part of that was thanks to Sam, our server. He was attentive without hovering, super knowledgeable about the menu, and made the whole night feel smooth and relaxed. Drinks were on point, timing was perfect, and he genuinely made us feel taken care of. If you’re dining here, ask for Sam — he knows what he’s doing. We’ll definitely be back.

Reddy our server was an amazing and accommodating server. He made sure at every course that was served that everything came out to our liking. The manager was always available and within eyesight and was active on the floor. The food was presentable and delicious. This was the second time I've been here and both times didnt disappoint. Would highly reccomend. Thank you for an enjoyable service.