Orange County Bagel

10/10 every time. Always coming here for bagels w cream cheese and this specific sandwich. I'm so picky about my italian sandwiches and this one is just perfect. It's called the Little Nicky sandwich, I got it on a roll. The people who work here are always so kind and amazing as well. <3 Edit: I see a lot of comments saying the woman who works is rude. I've had so many interactions with her, she answers the phone probably every time I've placed a pick up order and she's great. I've never had a bad experience here with any of the employees.

Bagels are ok, the attitude is not. The older lady that sometimes runs the register always has an attitude. She’s clearly being aggressive, but tries to pull it off as if she’s being nice by calling you dear and hon. I’ve had issues with her every time, but she really made me feel stupid the most recent visit. I simply wanted to pick out which Bagels I wanted. It was only 2. And I was the only customer. I’ve encountered some nice people there, so I hate to leave a mediocre review. It’s unfortunate she has to have an attitude every time. Overall, the bagels are OK, definitely not bad. The coffee is usually pretty good.

I tried to give this place another chance and yet it failed again. The food is just ok, nothing to write home about . But the attitude they have is so unprofessional. The older lady at the register is rude . I ordered two very simple items, a BEC with salt pepper and ketchup and a sesame bagel with scallion cream cheese. The guy who took my order seemed to have forgotten to write the bacon part down. When they brought my order they read it out and I mentioned politely it was supposed to be a Bacon egg and cheese. I was told I didn’t order it that way. Again, I politely said, I did, can we simply add bacon to it. The guy who took my Order reiterated I had not ordered it that way, again i politely stated I did and mistakes happen. I’m not upset, it was a simple fix. They seemed irritated . T

Orange County Bagel is the most amazing bagel eatery in the area, it’s always clean, the food is always delicious, and Jan, one of the nicest people I’ve ever met. If you haven’t been to Orange County Bagel in Walden, New York, you’re missing out.

Today I called, apparently, just before closing to place an order. (Tuesday, November 4th, 2025) I was told that I could get my order if I could pick it up in 5 minutes. Otherwise, "I guess I'll be taking it home with me." (With attitude. I asked if there was, possibly, any bacon made and was told "I don't think so!" Again...attitude! I ordered the Little Nicky, with LIGHT onions. The sandwich was advertised as having oil and vinegar. My son got there on time. The sandwich was overloaded with onions and DRY! No oil and vinegar at all! I will say that the macaroni and potato salads are delicious. And, the dill pickle is yummy! Too bad the attitude was bad, and the sandwich was so dry. Better luck next time!