Olivetto Pizzeria

Went there for the first time last weekend and the place was great. The atmosphere was casual and comfortable and the service was fantastic. Our waitress, I believe her name was Gigi, not sure though, was absolutely fantastic. She greeted us and was fast to bring drinks and take our order. Even made recommendations which we ordered and was great. Parking is no problem, the dining room is large, we didn’t have to wait for a table. Overall, this place is AAA+ We will be back again.

It's interesting the mixed reviews for this place. I recently moved into the area and came here without any knowledge. The pizza is decent and I find the staff courteous and helpful. The prices are reasonable. Recommended.

Old style Italian restaurant with mom and pop style sauce that tastes anything but ordinary. Their pizzas are to die for and they have so many unique options that I can’t find anywhere else like their penne vodka slice. Their manicotti is the best on Long Island, it’s so light and delicious it’s almost more of a crepe. You can tell they put a lot of love into their food.

10/10 loved the food was made fresh and served with passion. Atmosphere was like being in Italy. Workers are friendly!!! Overall very good pizza, must try!!

I have to say after 15yrs sadly I won’t b ordering from here anymore, $60 for two pies, veal parm hero and 2 pepperoni pinwheels.. the pizza has more crust then sauce or cheese and just really has gone down hill. Half the food was cold and they lost the cheese pie.. the margarita pie just looks pathetic and rushed…