Olde Mill Tavern

My wife Mary and I were joined last evening by good friends Bill and Lauren for dinner at Old Mill Tavern. We dine out together often and really enjoy discovering restaurants we haven’t tried before. Having lived in the area for three years (30 minutes away), I’ve also been on a personal quest to find the best prime rib around. First, a complement to our waiter, Bob. He was a joy, friendly, approachable, and great to joke around with. His service truly added to the experience. The atmosphere overall was warm and comfortable, exactly what you hope for on a relaxed night out with friends. Now, about that prime rib. I was looking for a larger cut than what was listed on the menu, and the kitchen was more than happy to accommodate my request. I ordered a 24 oz prime rib, and to say my 3 year s

This place is super cute. Went after skiing and the four of us were hangry. Prices at Pleasant Mtn for food were ridiculous and we needed someplace close and good. Food was GREAT, came out in under 15 minutes. Our server that evening was Don (I'm pretty sure) and he was awesome. AWESOME!! I have zero complaints and usually I can complain.

We went around 1ish and it wasn’t busy but it wasn’t completely empty. The food was fresh and tasty. It’s for sure a hidden gem! The places like it would a great local hotspot!

Would have been five stars, but they insisted I order my main course along with my appetizers and drink before she could place the order. I like to taste my appetizers and have a drink before I decide what I'm having has a main course. If the appetizer is really good I may just have another as my main course.

Great food, all 4 dinners and sides were very flavorful and cooked as requested. My friend said blackened salmon was best he ever had. Nice location in village of Harrison.