Old Yarmouth Inn Restaurant and Tavern

We had a wonderful dining experience from start to finish. Our server, Maria, was friendly, attentive, and genuinely added to the enjoyment of our evening. The food stood out for its clean, fresh flavors — nothing overwhelming, just well-balanced and delicious. We started with fresh ciabatta rolls and a beautifully piped brown‑butter floret, a simple but memorable touch. We shared the clam chowder and a blue crab cake with Dijon mustard sauce, both flavorful and well-prepared. For entrées, I ordered the pistachio‑crusted Icelandic cod over sun‑dried tomato risotto. The portion was generous, and the fish was perfectly cooked. The seafood trio — scallops, shrimp, and haddock, rice, and green beans — was another excellent choice, offering a nice variety without feeling heavy. My wife chose th

This was our first time at the Inn. I've been visiting the cape for my entire life and have grown tired of taking my mother to the same place.. So we wanted to try something new. The old yarmouth inn did not disappoint.We loved everything about our experience last night! The Thai calamari was different and delicious. The table had ordered short ribs, pistachio salmon, burger, pansearred scallops, and fish and chips. All of agreed that we would order our dishes again. The blood orange margarita did not disappoint either. We will definitely be back again to try more!

What a great historical restaurant in the heart of the cape. The people were very nice and always smiling. Even the servers were always checking on the patrons to see if they need anything. Our server was on top of her game knowing the specials. The food was great as were the drinks. The dessert is made in house and you can tell. The restaurant was very clean and the bar is very nice as well

I gotta say this place was a nice surprise. Not only is it inviting and decorated beautifully but the food is very good! We both enjoyed what we chose. Special touches like linen tablecloth service and pleasant staff made this a more elevated experience. We will definitely go back.

I recently visited this Yarmouth inn , and it was absolutely delicious. The highlight of my meal was the lobster—it was perfectly cooked, tender, and full of flavor. The rich butter sauce paired with it was incredible. The rest of the seafood was fresh and tasty as well. The staff was friendly and made sure everything was just right. If you love good lobster and fresh seafood, this place is a must-try. Highly recommended!